For some time now I have felt pulled in different directions and have been trying to pick apart my life and only present certain aspects in certain places where I believe they will be accepted. It’s one of the things that Autists are encouraged to do. You might see it called masking.
I tried to conform my use of plant medicine to fit with the modern Herbal Community™ and just write a separate blog for those interested in history. That just doesn’t work for me. My practices have always been informed by older methods that were handed down in my family and for a time I thought that meant they were “wrong” in some way because they didn’t line up.
I have different ideas about who was “wrong” now. The thing is that there’s nothing wrong with herbal clinicians basing their modern practice on medicinal texts published by doctors in the 19th century. That makes sense to me because we are working as professionals. I cringe inwardly at the home herbalist classes being offered because they speak to a practice that didn’t really exist.
As I believe I have said before, grandmothers would collectively spit tea through their noses laughing if they saw you all drinking nettles infusions every day. They would also laugh at the idea people fed their children slippery elm gruel when they weren’t sick. They actually might be concerned if they saw you drinking the chicken food (comfrey) every day because why would you do that unless you had a bleeding ulcer or something? (This does not mean you should treat your own bleeding ulcer, however I might suggest this as an adjunct, but probably not. Plantain works just as well if you make it right.)
For a group of people who try to use historic precedent as a selling point, many of you know truly little about what people actually did and lord knows many of you have spoken down to me when I tried to bring it up.
There’s a lot of marketing around this idea that we need an “herbalist” in every home and as the herbalists you model yourselves after were 19th century physicians responding to acute situations with strong preparations, I could not more strongly disagree.
What we need in every home are people who know how to take care of themselves with enough common sense to know when they are in over their heads and consult the professional healthcare provider of their choice. I don’t see that being taught. In fact, I see most people teaching a distrust for modern medicine that I won’t stand for anymore in light of the covid mess.
I love science and I am thankful for modern medicine. I become very excited when I stumble across some research that at least sheds some light on why a particular historical practice might be useful even though the people who first used them didn’t have the knowledge we have today.
This is the approach I take to teaching historical remedies at herbal conferences. People who have taken one of my classes know that I am absolutely giddy about the fact that it was discovered that that α-amylase in cabbage, potatoes, and wheat bran helps to thwart bacteria from building harmful biofilm communities by dissolving EPS shells, because now I understand poultices better.
When you look back at early modern domestic manuscripts you are going to find evidence of mutual respect. Physicians who wrote back-and-forth with their patients didn’t doubt their capacity to acquire or make a preparation and administer it. Some women were even known for their expansive knowledge of medicine and entertained male scholars at dinner parties where they discussed such thing. That’s how receipts attributed to people like John Locke end up in the domestic medicine manuscripts.
That’s unfortunately something that has vanished. When I was a kid my family doctor had grown up in a family like mine and so he had nothing negative to say about things my mom did to take care of us. He’d seen them help too many times. It is true that it’s really hard to find doctors like that now.
I have also been hesitant to talk about my use of herbal folkways in spaces where academic people would turn up their nose and snub them which is a shame because there is a lot to be learned from a time when physicians and those engaging in domestic medicine worked more closely together. I raised my children in this manner with great success.
My two younger children who are now 20 and 17 have never needed to visit a physician other than for their yearly physicals and to get their vaccinations. I navigated all the typical illnesses that are not preventable by modern science, by using home remedies that made them more comfortable and took the edge off symptoms. I even had a go at working with Covid recently.
My methods seem to have been reasonably effective at warding off secondary infections, as neither of them has ever needed antibiotics and their older sisters only needed them a few times.
I think that the women of the early modern era might better understand me than my modern colleagues do. Navigating domestic practice requires that one learns a variety of skills, especially if one doesn’t have a lot of money.
I grew up learning to grow, prepare and preserve from my grandparents and my parents because that was the least expensive way for them take care of their families.
I personally became an herbal clinician because I couldn’t afford to hire one. I completely understand my privilege in being able to pursue that education. I couldn’t afford to go to college until I was in my 30’s and it took me ten years to finish.
I can’t tell you frequently or often enough that you don’t need to do that to learn to take care of yourself. In fact, I advise against it because I am going to be in debt for the rest of my life, and I don’t have it in me to become enough of a marketing nightmare to make money.
I am pulling my most practical information into one place and focusing on rebuilding an informed popular health culture. If you want to come along for the journey, join me on https://www.domestic-medicine.com